Issues and Positions

Workers Compensation


Chamber-Opposed Workers' Compensation Proposal Signed Into Law

Legislation increasing workers' compensation benefits but lacking sufficient
reforms to offset employer costs was signed by the Governor on Friday at a
press conference in Los Angeles.

California Chamber-opposed AB 749 (Calderon) increases workers' compensation
system costs by $3.5 billion without making meaningful structural or
systemic changes that would offset costs to employers.

“The California Chamber is disappointed that AB 749 has become law,” states
Allan Zaremberg, president, California Chamber. “This legislation is too
costly for California businesses, and only adds to the heavy financial
burdens that employers already face.”

The Chamber believes that the cost savings from reforms in AB 749 are
speculative and uncertain, and are not enough to alleviate substantial
premium increases for California employers. Businesses already have
experienced a 77 percent increase in workers' compensation premiums since
1998.

The Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau estimates that total
system costs for workers' compensation without the benefit increases in AB
749 will exceed $154 billion by 2003.

The Chamber has consistently supported increased benefits to severely
injured workers, as long as they were coupled with significant cost-saving
reforms. While this law may be better than past proposals, the Chamber
believes AB 749 does not address the system inefficiencies that mean
employers still will be paying some of the highest workers' compensation
premiums in the nation even though the level of benefits for injured workers
will rise from 49th in the nation to 45th. The Chamber believes that there
are many more reforms in the workers' compensation system that will need to
be addressed by the Legislature.

“Because of the high costs of AB 749, California employers will have to make
a difficult and unfortunate decision -- either pass on the higher costs to
consumers, or cut jobs and leave people out of work,” states Zaremberg.
(Information provided by California Chamber at www.calchamber.com)

Summary:

The current Workers' Compensation legislation (SB 1156 - Burton) could be dropped and replaced with a new bill (AB 749 - Calderon). The California Chamber sent out an action alert e-mail earlier this week asking businesses to write their legislator opposing SB 1156. Due to this new information, businesses may wish to hold off writing in opposition to SB 1156 and wait for further information on the new workers' compensation bill, AB 749.

The El Segundo Chamber published the following letter opposing SB71 and urged all members to contact the Governor and oppose it. The Governor vetoed this bill. A workers compensation sub-committee of the Government Affairs Committee is continuing to monitor this legislation.

September 10, 2001

The Honorable Gray Davis
Governor of California
State Capitol
Sacramento, CA 95814
Fax: (916) 445-4633

Re: Workers Compensation - Senate Bill 71 (Burton)

Dear Governor Davis:

The El Segundo Chamber of Commerce recognizes that reform is necessary to workers compensation. Unfortunately, it appears SB71 (Burton) will increase employer premiums without offering any substantial reform to the system. As a result, we urge you to VETO SB71 (Burton).

El Segundo is comprised of over 2,000 businesses. While we count more Fortune 500 businesses than any city in California except for San Francisco, El Segundo also includes a large number of small businesses.

Many businesses have already seen their workers compensation premiums increase by 25% to 50%, while workers compensation fraud has also dramatically increased. In fact, the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Bureau (WCIRB) issued preliminary estimates that SB71 would increase benefit costs by 26.9% or $3.6 billion dollars by 2006.

We need a workers compensation system with increased efficiencies achieved by reducing costs of administering benefits while increasing benefits to those who need it. Reform that does not penalize businesses, yet offers relief to severely injured employees, would include:

  • limiting unnecessary and excessive medical treatments;
  • improving programs that offer quality medical treatment and focus on returning workers to work;
  • increasing penalties for those who entice workers to file fraudulent claims;
  • developing objective guidelines for determining disability ratings;
  • streamlining confusing and duplicative paperwork for employers and workers; and
  • allowing employers to challenge suspicious medical tests and treatments.

Your help is needed. Please VETO SB71 and encourage true reform to workers compensation.

Sincerely,

Liz West
President
El Segundo Chamber of Commerce